This is such a toughie! I think since you like the second girl so much and so do I XD plus, you're not too sure on the breeding bit, get her! Rather have the girl you really liked than the other who you may or may not breed with Skittles... But it's your call :)
"You are forever responsible for what you have tamed."
Betta love: it's an international thing.
Azure, Sterling, you will be with me forever. Peaches, my crazy girl, I'll miss you the most.
The Boys: Tranny, Inky "Yume" Zuko, Mao, Onishiki, Chopin, Maelstrom, Kabuki
The Girls: Kamikaze, Beeuty Qveen, Beefcake!, Chunkers, Awesome Sauce
Meeces: Koko, Bijli, Baadal, Barkha
Turtle: Hi Handsome (female -__-)