o.o Tabbies don't even have blue eyes! lol
They way I saw it with my dog is as long as it was holistic I didn't care, as he was old and ate a lot of substitution foods anyway (yogurt, eggs, chicken,). His Holistic Blend cost about 20$ a bag (lasted him 2-3 weeks).. I see some of these expensive crazy foods for dogs but they still contain corn and by products -_- It's worth the price if they are clean good foods but it's ultimately up to the owner to find what's right for their pet.
Since cats are different and by nature are obligate carnivores I would never feed my cat something like that. He only gets meat food, holistic and absolutely no corn, grains, by products. There is some unnecessary fruits and vegs in Oliver's kibble but he's perfectly healthy and they're in small amounts anyway (just to appeal to humans who think cats need that stuff)
Blah, pet nutrition. Always a gray area for debate.