Yup, definitely. His prices are good and he has tons of positive feedback...I'm hoping this is just a mistake, and if so, I will DEFINITELY clear his name on here as a good seller. I have messaged him, and will give him 24 hours to get back to me before I open a dispute via paypal and ebay.
The shipping isn't much, and I honestly don't really mind paying it, it's the principle of the thing, and the fact that the plants now have to spent two extra days at the post office in transit because I wasn't here to pick them up for the unknown COD charges. :P (Plants would be okay on the doorstep for an afternoon, fish I would have been home to pick up immediately.) THAT'S what has really made me angry.
Anyway, still waiting for a reply, I'll let everybody know what the end result is. I just wanted to warn people in the meantime just in case. :)