Wow, the first guy is very pretty, but if I as a pet owner and not a breeder ever spent more than $20 on a fish (before shipping), I would consider myself crazy! So, yes, gorgeous fish, and I know you'll never find one like him in a pet store, but I'm okay with that!
As for the CT, I'm no expert, and I'm not particularly fond of them, since they seem to me to always look like their fins are in disarray, but I don't see any issue with that boy's fins. He looks like he has a double ray going on, but again, no expert. Another pretty find, though!