Nice fish on AB, good breeder?

[MaisyDawgThirteen]

http://www.aquabid.com/cgi-bin/aucti...hmp&1350529425
I have no plans on breeding, but I'd like to learn more about form. I think like her fins, they are nice and even. Would she be a good breeder?

[MaisyDawgThirteen]

http://www.aquabid.com/cgi-bin/aucti...hmp&1350705658
Same with this girl.

[Myates]

Cute girls.. I would lean towards the first one over the second. Her tail is almost what you are looking for. The second girl just seemed to have too round of a tail for an HM, imo.

[VictorP]

If these were the only two fish available then I would choose female number 1 (no offense). Reason being is she has nicer finnage for an asymmetrical hmpk. Although their toplines seem a bit iffy to me and female number 1's dorsal is a bit far back on it's body.

[indjo]

Female #1 is better - as stated above. Dorsal could be better - you want the front rays to lean forward or at least be up right (not lean back).

Female #2 has too round caudal and very poor dorsal, small and does not open like a fan.