So it looks like Fishstick might be dying... I noticed his eyes were bulging a bit a few days ago and that they had started to color oddly (when I got him they were a dark gold-ish color, now they are pure gold and have blue cloudy bits). So I started treating him for possible pop-eye and separated him out of the divided tank that he was sharing with Shiny and swaped him into Button's 2gal bowl (it has a hydor heater). Today I got up and fed my fishies and he was completely vertical and he's really pale and lethargic (I almost thought he died this morning). I also changed his water today and after that he started swimming around a bit and he's moving really oddly, like he can't coordinate his fins properly.
I don't think there's much I can really do at this point... but if anyone has any suggestions, I'm open to them. In the mean time I'm going to continue treating him with a reduced dose of Melafix for pop-eye and hope.