Betta Fish Forum banner

AQ salt vs. Epsom Salts?

2K views 19 replies 5 participants last post by  Hallyx  
#1 ·
Can someone help me with this debate I offer have for myself? I often see AQ salt and Epsom suggested for illnesses almost interchangeably. Like for treating bloat for example I see some people say use Epsom others AQ salt. So can someone help me with what's the differences or what you prefer?
 
#2 ·
Ooooh no no no! AQ salt is definitely not for bloat lol. Okay here's the difference:

AQ salt balances out electrolytes and invigorates the slime coat which makes them overproduce their coat and eventually shed it which is good for external parasites like Ich and sometimes early Velvet. However, AQ salt like most salts actually makes the fish retain fluids including water, which can make a fish become bloated if used too long or too much/too often. AQ salt can be rather harsh on their systems as well if they're already compromised and this makes their liver's/kidney's work ten times more which can sometimes lead to organ failure.

Epsom salt is a natural laxative and is often used on horses and our feet to soothe swelling and heat. In fish it's good for flushing out their system if they have internal parasites or constipation, both which can lead to a bloated fish.

So in a general way of saying; AQ salt for external stuff and ES for internal stuff.
 
#6 ·
Salt (Sodium chloride) NaCl, When dissolved in water, the sodium chloride framework disintegrates as the Na+ and Cl− ions become surrounded by the polar water molecules. Cl- ions cross the gill membrane rise the Potential osmotic pressure on the fish
Many micro organisms cannot live in an overly salty environment: water is drawn out of their cells by osmosis.

Epsom salt(Magnesium sulfate)MgSO4 Almost all known mineralogical forms of MgSO4 occur as hydrates MgSO4·7H2O The anhydrous form is strongly hygroscopic, and can be used as a desiccant. water is drawn out cells by osmosis just like NaCl but Magnesium sulfate rise KH and binds with calcium carbonate

R
 
#8 ·
Salt (Sodium chloride) NaCl, When dissolved in water, the sodium chloride framework disintegrates as the Na+ and Cl− ions become surrounded by the polar water molecules. Cl- ions cross the gill membrane rise the Potential osmotic pressure on the fish
Many micro organisms cannot live in an overly salty environment: water is drawn out of their cells by osmosis.

Epsom salt(Magnesium sulfate)MgSO4 Almost all known mineralogical forms of MgSO4 occur as hydrates MgSO4·7H2O The anhydrous form is strongly hygroscopic, and can be used as a desiccant. water is drawn out cells by osmosis just like NaCl but Magnesium sulfate rise KH and binds with calcium carbonate

R
I love it when Rickey talks chem.
 
#12 ·
I also agree, however I do have to use conditioner because I have other things in my tap water unfortunately :-/ too close to the city.

But so many people don't realize that 75% of the time, all a fish needs is good clean, warm water. Not all these fancy medications and especially not salts. I used to advocate for salts but I try to stay away as much as I can and not recommend it after seeing fish die of organ failure after salt usages. It's purely situational but at the same time, I don't feel like risking my fish when all they need is clean water.
 
#17 · (Edited)
My well has been tested as having heavy metals. (I'd have to find the test results to tell you which ones). I use 1-drop/gal Prime to chelate the metal, although I'd rather not.

Rick, your's is the kind of great info I'd like to see on that advanced thread we're talking about. Not hidden here off-topic on a basic thread about salt..
 
#18 ·
Rick, your's is the kind of great info I'd like to see on that advanced thread we're talking about. Not hidden here off-topic on a basic thread about salt..
I would like to see an advanced water chemistry thread started somewhere but most people rarely care, most think the answer is always in a bottle.

R